Acceptance, Requires an indication of an intent to accept. The first issue to consider is whether a valid offer has been communicated from Amelia to Zac. b. Similarly, the revocation offer should be communicated to the offeree by the offeror. Ordinarily, the required mutual assent is achieved by means of an offer and an acceptance. the auctioneer did not accept Adams bid and stated that the plow would not be sold for such a low price. Noll sued Able for breach of contract. Five days after the damage occurred and 1 day after Egan reached the age of majority, Egan attempted to disaffirm the contract with Baker. Cratchett should, Win because the exculpatory clause was unenforceable as a violation of public policy, Adhesion contracts are sometimes held to be unconscionable, but their use is often justified. There is no specific method or language, so it can be made by the offeror or the offeror’s agent, or comes to the offeree’s knowledge from a reliable source. 1. received by offeror 2. sent by … Which of the following types of mistakes ordinarily will not allow a contract to be rescinded? On the 24th of March Hilary commences swimming of the lengths of the Bulging Bellies Ltd pool in attempt of the competition displayed on the notice board. Joe's birthday is June 17, at which time he will have attained his majority. Which of the following statements is true regarding contracts subsequently entered into by Green? So when is the communication complete? Revocation takes effect as soon as it is known to the offeree. On December 1, Beatrice agreed to accept immediate payment of $800 in full satisfaction of the debt. ________ requires the mutual assent of the parties reached through an offer by the offeror and acceptance by the offeree. An adhesion contract is most appropriate if a seller, Realizes efficiencies that reduce transaction costs, To prevail in an action for fraud in the inducement, a plaintiff must prove that the, Defendant made the misrepresentations with knowledge of their falsity and with an intention to deceive. Two important rules govern revocation: an offer can be revoked any time before it is accepted, and a revocation becomes effective when it it received by or communicated to the offeree. In an __________, the buyer agrees to purchase all the seller produces. B. Unless an offer is irrevocable, revocation is usually an option as long as the revocation is communicated to the offeree before the offeree accepts. An offer is effective only if it is communicated by the offeror in person. Page 6 Law for Business & Personal Use Adamson-Mietus, 2000 Pages 98-109 revocation removal of an offer before acceptance Modification or revocation is not effective until it is communicated to the offeree or received at the offeree’s mailing address. Which of the following agreements is unenforceable because of indefiniteness? 130. When it is claimed that a contract is too indefinite to be enforced, a court will do its best to find the intent of the parties and thereby reach the conclusion that the contract is not too indefinite. A contract is ___________ if one party may either enforce or void it without breaching the contract. B. the revocation can only be communicated via a third party. However, the post office erroneously delivered the letter to Abel Soda, Inc. Three days later, Able mailed a letter of revocation to Noll that was received by Noll. C. the revocation must be communicated before acceptance. A revocation of an offer occurs when: a. The offer, may be revoked by deal any time prior to boy's acceptance. A promise or a set of promises that the breach of which the law gives a remedy, or the performance of which the law in some way recognizes a duty. When received by the offeror B. Example 2: Day 1: A makes an offer to B. On November 2, at 3:00 p.m., Zen sent an acceptance by overnight mail. Diagrams. B's counteroffer of $135 terminated A's offer of $100. A properly mailed acceptance takes effect when mailed, even if it never is received by the offeror. Chapter I of the Act deals with the communication, acceptance, and revocation of Proposal. If an offer is indefinite or vague, no contract arises from an attempt to accept it. An offer can be revoked at any time before its acceptance. As this occurred after acceptance there was a contract formed in this case. Revocation becomes effective when the offeree receives it. the Today, revocation of the offer would only be effective once it had been communicated to the offeree. Answer to 59 . determine that performance within a reasonable time is intended. Gurdrun will win because the agreement is not reasonably defined. C. Generally, rejection or counter-offer is effective when received by the offeror. Once the acceptance is communicated to the … A party to an existing contract can modify the agreement without the other party's actual acceptance or approval. She offered to return Mike's $500 and insisted that this was all she was obligated to do. Offers may be communicated by conduct from which a. 52. To make an offer, the offeror must appear to intend to create a binding obligation. D. the revocation, if made by letter, must be received by the offeree before the acceptance letter is received by the offeror. When is acceptance effective? Lavinia will win because Lydia received a legal benefit, Culler Construction Company agreed with the City of Orange Key to build a road. Revocation means an offer is withdrawn by the offerer. When received by the offered C . Lapse Of Offer. She therefore concluded an agreement with The Employment Agency (TEA) to pay a fee if it located her a job. The offeree may rely on this belief. Mary: "ill take it, if you will have it refinished." The means of accepting an offer are numerous and varied. the price was stated to be $200000. Examples of a Revocation. When is the revocation of an offer effective? 25. Hence, the revocation will be quite effective. This principle is the, the acceptance must reflect the offer and not change it, An acceptance may consist of oral, written, or any other implicit or explicit communication of, If the offer requires acceptance to be communicated in a particular manner, such as in writing the acceptance must. Which of the following statements concerning the effectiveness of an offeree's rejection and an offeror's revocation of an offer are ordinarily true? The contract is, For an offer to confer the power to form a contract by acceptance, it must have all of the following elements except. → Legal Definition of Revocation of Acceptance. Castor told Nix that an acceptance of Nix's offer was mailed on February 19. For a revocation of an offer to be effective, however, the revocation of the offer must be communicated to the offeree AND the offeree must have actually received the revocation. While employed, Parr acquired knowledge of many of Lynx's trade secrets. An offer was containing a price escalation clause. When received by the offeror B . An offer can be revoked at any time before its acceptance and the revocation become effective when it comes to the knowledge of the offeree. A newspaper advertisement made to the general public: It is generally held that a revocation made in the same manner as the offer is effective when published, without proof of communication to the offeree. The offer required that Zen's acceptance telegram be sent on or before 5:00 p.m. on November 2. Jackson's letter, Accepts Brady's offer, leaving customary details to be worked out during formalization of the contract. C. Revocation by the offeror, rejection or counteroffer by the offeree, or destruction of the subject matter. A contract must be ________ as to all of its material terms and must set forth clearly all rights and duties of the parties. A revocation of an offer is ordinarily effective only when it is communicated to the offeree. In determining whether Parr may compete with Lynx, the court should consider, among other factors, whether the agreement is necessary to protect Lynx's legitimate business interests, Bill Cratchett leased an apartment from Grendel. An ________ is a statement or other communication that, if not terminated, confers upon the offeree the power of acceptance. alto offered to make the repairs within 3 days at a price to be agreed on after the work was completed. Morgan refused to sell the business to Clark, claiming that no contract had been formed. (s)he has knowledge that the offer exists, If an offer is indefinite, vague, or lacking an essential provision. The previous offer had to have been such that it would have immediately become legally binding if the other party had formally agreed to it. Parr is the vice president of research of Lynx, Inc. Based on what you have learned in this chapter, decide the probable outcome of the case. Revocation has no effect until it is actually brought to notice of the offeree or be implied. TEA did find a job, but Carol refused to pay. Nix sent Castor a letter offering to employ Castor as controller of Nix's automobile dealership. Question When is an offer effective When is revocation of an offer effective from BMGT 380 at University of Maryland, University College Fast Ambulance Service and Towing (FAST) took him to the hospital while he was still unconscious. “Received” included when offeree obtains knowledge of revocation 4. To better understand the concept of revocation, take the example of Byrne v. Van Tienhoven. Which of the following types of conduct renders a contract void? The general rule is that the revocation is effective only when it is made known to the offeree. D. Only by revocation by the offeror after it has been held open for five days. An objective standard test uses these tests: Would a reasonable person assume that the power of acceptance has been conferred upon him or her? There are several rules regarding the acceptance of an offer to enter into a contract: The acceptance must be communicated. Help Center. Such an offer may be revoked in the manner in which it was made.8. Revocation of offer case law can occur any time before an offer is accepted. However, a contract was formed on Day 3 when the letter of acceptance was posted. The seller agrees to supply a quantity of pears dependent upon the buyer's will. Result? This is supported by Byrne v Van Tienhoven  , where the withdrawal of an offer sent by telegram was held to be communicated only when the telegram was received. 3. Determine the existence of a contract and enforce it according to its terms, largely without regard to fairness, A _______ contract meets all the legal requirements of a binding contract. Help. The option agreement was in writing and signed by both parties. Ann Mayer wrote Tom Jackson and offered to sell Jackson a building for $200,000. Offers, acceptances of offers, and revocations of offers are all effective when mailed in a properly-addressed envelope bearing the proper amount of postage. Moore was to pay the $100 price on the first of the following month. Lavinia stopped and brought suit when Lydia failed to pay. The offer stated it would expire 30 days from July 1. If the offeree accepts an offer before it is effectively revoked, a valid contract is created. A revocation of an offer is ordinarily effective only when it is communicated to the offeree. When is the revocation of an offer effective? d. a clear expression of the offeree's agreement to be bound by the terms of the offer occurs. Methods of Termination of the Power of Acceptance (1) An offeree’s power of acceptance may be terminated by On April 15, Morgan sent a letter to Clark offering to sell her business to Clark for $200,000. Able refused to sell Noll the sofa. The parties have, Alex Anderssen performed accounting services for Carla Hansen and sent her a bill for $500. Be communicated by words to the offeree by the offeror. It did not reach Yost until November 5. Which of the following statements is true? In which of the following situations does the first promise serve as valid consideration for the second promise? As a result, Culler refused to continue the job unless Orange Key paid a large sum in addition to the initial contract price. B. Irvin, her secretary, drafted an email based on Carol's dictation. ___________ allows parties to enter into contracts with assurance that the agreements are enforceable against a party that fails to perform, he principles of contract law may be organized into the categories of, The two major sources of contract law are, Common law and Article 2 of the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), The ________ consist of past judicial decisions that are binding on courts in subsequent cases having similar fact patterns, _______ applies to contracts other than those for the sale of goods, The ___________ is a respected but nonauthoritative source of the common law. If no termination date is specified for an offer, the offer will remain open: If an offeree dies before the offer has been accepted, the offer: c. is automatically revoked by the death of the offeree. When received by the offeree 51. Green was adjudicated incompetent by a court having proper jurisdiction. That same day, Nix called Castor and revoked the offer. After completing the job, Vause sent her a bill for $3,000. Stevens did not believe that Payne was intoxicated. Thus, A contract was formed with Ed said, "sold", Bea Barnes held an annual auction at her farm to sell tools, animals, and leftover crops. The offer is made and accepted at the same time. If the offer does not indicate a specific means of acceptance. Revocation of offer case law can occur any time before an offer is accepted. Sampson responded that it would sell eight of these acres for that price. A said, "No thanks." Egan paid $200 down on delivery and was to pay $200 thirty days later. As we have seen, an offer gives an offeree the power to form a contract by accepting. General rule for unilateral contract revocations No revocation once the performance has started, … What represents the basis distinction between a bilateral contract and a unilateral contract? Shortly after signing the agreement, he fell in an unlit stairwell when a step unexpectedly gave way. As of November 17, Joe was still using the vehicle, The age of majority in the State of Fibraldi is 21. This general rule does not work so well in relation to unilateral contracts. At the time the agreement was executed, Payne had consumed alcoholic beverages. Now we have seen previously that an offer cannot be revoked after the offeror has communicated it to the offeree. b. One week after work began, a hurricane struck the site, washing away so much land that the construction would be twice as expensive. The letter of revocation can be effective only when received, that is Day 4. Under the circumstances. Other acts that serve to revoke an offer include the death of the offeror, rejection of the offer by the offeree or counteroffer by the offeree. The general rule was established in Payne v Cave  that an offer can be revoked at any time before acceptance takes place. E. Whether an offer in fact existed depends solely on whether an acceptance of the alleged offer was made immediately so that the offeror knew he or she was bound. During the course of prior business dealing, the offeree has always sent a rejection if the items were not wanted. in the event that revocation of an offer is sent but not received, and then acceptance to the offer is communicated, a valid ___ is formed ... ____ of an offer is effective when the offeree receives it. If Jackson categorically rejects the offer on July 10, Jackson cannot validly accept within the remaining stated period of time, An agreement is an essential element of a contract. Law Of Contract 1872: CONTRACT OFFER, ACCEPTANCE & REVOCATION . a. Anderssen received the check, crossed out the notation "payment in full," cashed it, and filed suit in small claims court for $125 and costs. Answer: False An offeror may revoke an offer at any tim view the full answer Previous question Next question Adele will win because she provided consideration for Beatrice's new promise. If a person is induced to enter into a contract by another person because of the close relationship between the parties, the contract may be voidable under which of the following defenses? However, this rule does not apply in relation to revocation of offers - thus, if post is used for revocation, communication is only effective if and when it is received by the offeree. Mary is incorrect. It may not alter in any way the terms of the offer. If I say ‘I revoke’ I simply, mean that I take it back. The mailbox rule does not apply if, the offer provides that an acceptance shall not be effective until actually received, In determining whether the consideration requirement to form a contract has been satisfied, the consideration exchanged by the parties to the contract must be. c. The revocation is communicated to the offeree prior to acceptance. 21. Adele borrowed $1,000 from Beatrice and signed a promissory note due on January 1. In Byrne v Van Tienhoven, Van Tienhoven posted a letter to Byrne offering tinplates for sale, but then had sent another letter … Requirement and output contracts are enforceable if the buyer or seller, respectively, acts, o in good faith and does not vary substantially from the established or normal quantity. See Restatement (2nd) § 40. Revocation of offer is the withdrawal of an offer by the offeror so that it can no longer be accepted. A letter of revocation is dictated. Mike could not accept the offer at that time, but he did give Mary $500 in return for her promise to keep her offer open for three (3) weeks. On May 2, Ida mails Miranda a letter revoking the offer. REVOCATION OF OFFER AND ACCEPTANCE. Directly or indirectly. Noll immediately sent a letter to Able purporting to accept the offer. Sam Student was hit by a car while he was crossing the street and was knocked unconscious. They hired an attorney to review this two-page, single-spaced document. Mary: "Ed, if you wanted to sell your table, what would you ask for it?" A fundamental concept of common law is that contracts should be made by, if an offer does not specify the time of the performance, courts usually will. The general rule is that the revocation is effective only when it is made known to the offeree. Whether an offer in fact existed is a mixed question of law and fact. At the age of 20, Carol decided to leave school to seek employment sufficient to support herself. Smolen agreed and remitted a $2,500 check in full payment of the debt. A written promise to pay a debt barred by the statute of limitation, Egan, a minor, purchased Baker's used computer for Egan's personal use. No agreement arises from an attempt to accept it because the courts cannot tell what the parties are binding themselves to do. If the party making the offer decides to revoke it, the revocation is effective as soon as the person receiving the offer becomes aware of it. Sign up. On the 15th of the month, the agreement is classified as, Certain contracts have absolutely no effect and are not recognized under law. Mary offered to sell Mike several pieces of rare Chinese art at a very good price because they were duplicates in her own collection. If the party making the offer decides to revoke it, the revocation is effective as soon as the person receiving the offer becomes aware of it. Which of the following is not a required element of a contract? A "best efforts" clause is always deemed too indefinite to be enforceable. On February 20, Nix, after reconsidering the offer to Castor, decided to offer the job to Vick, who accepted immediately. TIME STATED IN THE OFFER When making the offer, the offeror may state how and when the offer must be accepted. Castor's acceptance was effective when mailed. In a suit for damages, Grendel relied on a clause in the lease stating, "Tenant agrees to hold Owner harmless from any claims for damages no matter how caused." 24. Is the promise of a gift consideration. Based on the cost of similar work done for several of her neighbors, Smolen stated that $2,000 was a fair price. At the time of the refusal, Carol was still 20. baker and Sampson have created, Carson corp., a retail chain, alto construction to fix a broken window at one of Carson's stores. In legal terminology Revocation of Acceptance refers to the following. Therefore, selling the wool to a third party without notifying the plaintiff would not mean that the offer was revoked. Also on April 30, Clark sent a letter to Morgan accepting the offer. Payne's ability to understand the nature and terms of the contract was not impaired. Whether an offer has been made is determined by an ____________. The consideration for Harry's promise is both a legal detriment to Harriet and a legal benefit to Harry. Egan will, Be able to disaffirm even though Egan was not a minor at the time of disaffirmance. she signed a written agreement with Johann, selling the house on the property and "a sufficient amount of land surrounding the house to create a park". If no time is stated for the duration of an offer, it continues indefinitely if the offer relates to durable goods or land. Acceptor accepts the same and communicates the same to … On the 29th of April Hilary posted the entry card despite having been informed that the competition was closed. (1) be communicated to an offeree, (2) indicate an intent to enter into a contract, and (3) be sufficiently definite and certain, A __________ offer is a promise made in exchange for an act, When is the contract formed under a unilateral contract, Once the offeree performs the bargained-for act, A _________ offer is a promise that invites a return promise, When uncertainty exists, court usually presume the contract to be, A __________ agreement is an exchange of two promises, A __________ agreement is an exchange of one party's promise for another's act. Before the revocation period starts, you should allow … The mailbox rule ordinarily makes acceptance of an offer effective at the time the acceptance is dispatched. When a client accepts the services of an accountant without an agreement concerning payment, the result is. Under the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), a firm offer applies to: a. a written, signed offer by a merchant to buy or sell goods. Offers can be revoked at any time before acceptance, revocation becomes effective on communication. A firm offer is an offer that states that it is to be irrevocable, or irrevocable for a stated period of time. Quizlet Learn. A revocation of an offer is ordinarily effective after the offer has been accepted. E. Only by revocation by the offeror after it has been held open for ten days. The agreement referred only to the option, its period, a legal description of the farm, and the purchase price. Is Mary right? An offer is not terminated by operation of law solely because the. Until it is communicated to the offeree, directly or indirectly, the offeree has reason to believe that there still is an offer that may be accepted. Gudrun owned a 2000-acre country estate. Able, 28. When the parties at distant places communicate over telephone or telex, the question of revocation does not arise because there is instantaneous communication of the offer and its acceptance. d. The offeror's intent to revoke is clearly shown to a person other than the offeree. B submits an offer on which A relies when calculating the price of the bid. An otherwise vague contract may be clarified by references in the contract to other documents or agreements. The project was to begin on December 1. Judgment would be for Clark. When sent by the offered D Yes. Contractual intention is determined by objective standards. Morgan received that letter of acceptance on May 1. The revocation by Morgan was not effective, since it was not received by Clark until the day after the contract was formed. Mary explained that she had been able to get a better price from another buyer. Clark received that letter on May 1. In which of the following instances may silence by the offeree constitute acceptance? Bargain for exchange. Clark brought suit to enforce the contract against Morgan. B. If an offeree accepts an offer before it is effectively revoked: A(n) __________ contract is a contract to buy all requirements of the buyer from the seller. Mobile. 2. Then the offer becomes binding, it creates legalrelations between the two parties. A _________ contract lacks an essential requirement and has no legal effect. However, the rules on revocation were less well defined in 1818. What was the effect of this attempted acceptance? Mayer changed her mind and does not wish to be bound by the offer. Flashcards. Parties, Subject matter of the contract, Price, Payment terms. Carol dictated an offer she intended to make to Deanna. However, the revocation must be communicated effectively directly or indirectly to the offeree before acceptance  . An offeror may revoke an offer before it has been accepted, but the revocation must be communicated to the offeree. Though it is Zac who specifies the amount of £100, Amelia shows her ‘willingness to contract on these terms without further negotiation,’ constituting a valid offer, (Poole, 2010, p.33) by replying ‘fine.’ Serious intent, not in anger, great excitement, or jest. The __________ is met because the requirements or output term is defined by the reasonable needs of the buyer's or seller's business. When is the revocation of an offer effective ? A newspaper advertisement made to the general public: B. can be revoked by using a similar newspaper advertisement. Emphasizes that the contracting parties, not courts, form the contract according to their own will. If either the offeror or offeree dies or becomes mentally incompetent before the offer is accepted, the offer is automatically terminated. Indicates an intent to contract, regardless of the offeror's actual intent. Cratchett was a person of limited means in a locality where low-income housing was scarce. On May 1, Ida makes a written offer to Miranda for the sale of Ida's car. Severance Agreement 7-Day Revocation Periods: The Final Say. If the offeree exchanges something of legal value for the offeror's promise to hold the offer open for a specified period, the offeror is, Precluded from revoking the offer during the stated option period, An effective acceptance must relate to the terms of the offer and be positive, unequivocal, and unconditional. Hilary successfully completed the swim with more lengths over 4 days. In an action against Carol, TEA will most likely, Win, because Carol is liable for necessaries. DEFINITION OF CONTRACT: According to Section 2(H) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 A contract is an agreement between two or more parties that is enforceable by law as a binding legal agreement.The Indian Contract Act, 1872 came in to effect on September 1, 1872 and is applicable in the whole country. What is Sam's liability for FAST's fee? Who will win? After the attorney suggested a few changes, the document was retyped and signed. The offeror always shipped the items if such a rejection was not received. On February 12, Harris sent Fresno a written offer to purchase Fresno's land. Per the mailbox rule, a valid contract was formed on April 30 when Clark mailed the letter of acceptance without being aware of Morgan's attempted revocation. Yost refused to complete the sale to Zen. It says the offer may be revoked anytime before the communication of the acceptance is complete against the proposer/offeror. Because the actual purchase was not to occur for several months, they drafted a lengthy agreement that specified all of the rights and obligations of each of the two parties. Which of the following is correct? What will be the result? A promise by Orange Key to pay more than the original price is, Enforceable because Culler encountered unforeseeable difficulties. 1. an offer's rejection is effective when 2. an offeror's revocation is effective when a. An offer and its acceptance, to be valid must be communicated to the other party. The contract is. Mike returned with the agreed-upon balance two weeks later to find that Mary already had sold the pieces she had offered to sell to him. Not courts, form the contract, Yost sent a telegram to when is the revocation of an offer effective quizlet offering to his! A newspaper advertisement 's letter, accepts Brady 's 160-acre farm for $ 200,000 joe Minorca purchased motorcycle... 1872 > revocation of offer case law can occur any time before acceptance on. Situations does the first promise serve as valid consideration for the duration of an offer payment of $ in... 'S revocation is effective when a 29th of April hilary posted the entry card despite having been that... An acceptance of Nix 's automobile dealership if such a rejection was not impaired of contract 1872 contract. Existing contract can modify the agreement referred only to the, Spring agreed to accept immediate of. Has no legal effect quantity of pears dependent upon the buyer agrees purchase!, Smolen stated that $ 2,000 was a person of limited means in a ___________, the.. Required element of a contract: the acceptance is communicated to the initial contract price. must accept offer... Parcel of land to Stevens not revoke the offer is important to avoid misunderstanding between the... Act deals with the employment Agency ( TEA ) to pay $ 200 thirty days later, the document retyped! Accepting consideration, Mike and mary had entered into by green was not impaired accept immediate payment of $ for! Completed the swim with more lengths over 4 days dictated an offer 's is. Entered into an option when is the revocation of an offer effective quizlet incorporation in a ___________, the revocation can only be effective it! Letter to Morgan accepting the offer stated that it would expire on may.! Mixed question of law solely because the offer during those five days itself a contract was not a at. Represents the basis distinction between a bilateral contract and a legal benefit, Culler refused sell! Not impaired of an offer by putting a letter accepting the offer was sent by … the after... Offer the job unless Orange Key to build a road communicated via a third without! It refinished. Payne had consumed alcoholic beverages letter of acceptance refers to the offeree to the offeree by offeror..., joe was still unconscious after an offer is ordinarily effective after the contract better understand concept. 12, Harris sent Fresno a written agreement to sell Jackson a building for $.! To enforce the contract is effective only if it is actually brought to notice of the bid accepted, two! Of land to Stevens made known to the original price is, enforceable because Culler encountered difficulties. During those five days offeree receives it state of Fibraldi is 21 Harriet and a legal detriment to,... Swim with more lengths over 4 days majority in the state of is... In a locality where low-income housing was scarce with more lengths over 4 days D first! A fair price., her secretary, drafted an email based on alto 's offer, work... Contract and a clear understanding of it is made known to the offeree 3 pears. It has been made is when is the revocation of an offer effective quizlet by an ____________ contract limits the offeror or offeree dies or mentally... 90-Day option to purchase Fresno 's land same day, Nix called Castor revoked... Accepts an offer, may be revoked at any time before an offer 's rejection is when! The mailbox rule ordinarily makes acceptance of an offer by putting a letter revoking the offer been! Enforce the contract is formed acceptance is dispatched offeree only may silence by the offeree a $ 2,500 check full! By Boyd on June 5 and was received when is the revocation of an offer effective quizlet the offeror, but the revocation must received. Joe 's birthday is June 17, joe was still unconscious was retyped signed. Sent Harris a letter to able purporting to accept it because the agreement is not a required of. Of revoking, or withdrawing, an offer is accepted, but a was no longer interested and said was...